version control - Git and working on multiple branches

Question

I have a couple of Git branches: 'experimental', 'something' and 'master'.

I switched to the 'experimental' branch. I noticed a bug which is unrelated to 'experimental' and belongs to changes which have been made in 'something'. How should I fix it?

I'm thinking I should switch to 'something', fix the bug, commit and then move back to 'experimental'. How should I take the minor change from 'something' and apply it to both 'master' and 'experimental' so that I don't have to re-fix the bug again when I switch into these branches?

question from:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1334027/git-and-working-on-multiple-branches

Answer 1

There are two solutions not mentioned already that you can use: use a topic branch or use cherry-picking.

---

Topic branch solution

In the topic branch solution, you switch to branch 'something', create a branch to fix a bug e.g. 'something-bugfix', merge this branch into 'something' (fixing the bug), then merge this branch into 'experimental'.

$ git checkout -b something-fix something
[edit, commit]
$ git checkout something
$ git merge something-fix
$ git checkout experimental
$ git merge something-fix
[fix conflicts if necessary and commit]

See also Resolving conflicts/dependencies between topic branches early and Never merging back, and perhaps also Committing to a different branch blog posts by Junio C Hamano (git maintainer).

---

Cherry-picking a bugfix

The cherry-picking solution is useful if you noticed later that the bugfix you created (e.g. on development branch) would be useful also on other branch (e.g. stable branch). In your case you would comit a fix on 'something' branch:

$ git checkout something
[edit, edit, edit]
$ git commit
$ git checkout experimental

Then you noticed that fix you comitted in 'something' branch should be also on 'experimenta' branch. Lets say that this bugfix was commit 'A' (e.g. 'something' if you didn't commit anything on top of 'something', but it might be e.g. 'something~2' or 'c84fb911'):

$ git checkout experimental
$ git cherry-pick A

(you can use --edit option to git cherry-pick if you want to edit commit message before comitting cherry-picked bugfix).