algorithm - Triangle Triangle Intersection in 3d-Space

Question

I'm working with some 3d geometry. I need to find the intersection of triangle with another triangle.

What algorithm could I use?

Answer 1

Many people apparently rely on an implementation (link to source code) of the method described in 2006 in the following paper (link to PDF):

Tropp, Oren, Ayellet Tal, and Ilan Shimshoni. "A fast triangle to triangle intersection test for collision detection." Computer Animation and Virtual Worlds 17.5 (2006): 527-535.

There is however a problem with that code (except for adopting an old programming style, using unconventional notations and loosing the underlying geometrical interpretation): "determinant thing" don't necessarily make your math more robust, if done the wrong way.

I suggest to either use Moeller's method (link to PDF) or take a look at Delliver's paper (link to PDF), implemented in the CGAL library (link, "Triangle_3_Triangle_3_do_intersect.h").

An example: the intersection routine implemented above tells that the triangles (p0,p1,p2) and (q0,q1,q2) defined by the following points

p0 = (-21, -72, 63)
p1 = (-78, 99, 40)
p2 = (-19, -78, -83)
q0 = (96, 77, -51)
q1 = (-95, -1, -16)
q2 = (9, 5, -21)

are not intersecting. Here is a picture of the triangles:

And here is the code snippet (append to original code):

#include <iostream>

inline void setPoint(double p[3], const double x, const double y, const double z)
{
    p[0] = x; p[1] = y; p[2] = z;
}

inline void computeEdges(double v0[3], double v1[3], const double p0[3], const double p1[3], const double p2[3])
{
    v0[0] = p1[0]-p0[0];
    v0[1] = p1[1]-p0[1];
    v0[2] = p1[2]-p0[2];
    v1[0] = p2[0]-p0[0];
    v1[1] = p2[1]-p0[1];
    v1[2] = p2[2]-p0[2];
}

void main()
{
    unsigned int numErrors(0), count(0);
    double p0[3], p1[3], p2[3], q0[3], q1[3], q2[3];
    double v0[3], v1[3], w0[3], w1[3];
    bool res, answer;
    int ret;

    std::cout << "Testing the correctness of tr_tri_intersect3D" << std::endl;

    {
        // Non excluding triangles in generic positions, big determinants, intersecting
        ++count;
        setPoint(p0, -21, -72, 63);
        setPoint(p1, -78, 99, 40);
        setPoint(p2, -19, -78, -83);
        setPoint(q0, 96, 77, -51);
        setPoint(q1, -95, -1, -16);
        setPoint(q2, 9, 5, -21);
        answer = true;

        computeEdges(v0, v1, p0, p1, p2);
        computeEdges(w0, w1, q0, q1, q2);
        int ret = tr_tri_intersect3D(p0, v0, v1, q0, w0, w1);
        bool res = ( ret != 0 );

        if( res != answer )
        {
            std::cout << "# wrong answer on test " << count << "!
";
            ++numErrors;
        }
    }

}

A final note on the number of arithmetic operations: since the method takes in input pre-computed edge vectors, 12 +/- operations should be added to Table I. of the paper.

Last but not least: please verify what I am writing on your own and give me feedback if you think that I misunderstood something!