python - Should I create pipeline to save files with scrapy?

Question

I need to save a file (.pdf) but I'm unsure how to do it. I need to save .pdfs and store them in such a way that they are organized in a directories much like they are stored on the site I'm scraping them off.

From what I can gather I need to make a pipeline, but from what I understand pipelines save "Items" and "items" are just basic data like strings/numbers. Is saving files a proper use of pipelines, or should I save file in spider instead?

Answer 1

Yes and no[1]. If you fetch a pdf it will be stored in memory, but if the pdfs are not big enough to fill up your available memory so it is ok.

You could save the pdf in the spider callback:

def parse_listing(self, response):
    # ... extract pdf urls
    for url in pdf_urls:
        yield Request(url, callback=self.save_pdf)

def save_pdf(self, response):
    path = self.get_path(response.url)
    with open(path, "wb") as f:
        f.write(response.body)

If you choose to do it in a pipeline:

# in the spider
def parse_pdf(self, response):
    i = MyItem()
    i['body'] = response.body
    i['url'] = response.url
    # you can add more metadata to the item
    return i

# in your pipeline
def process_item(self, item, spider):
    path = self.get_path(item['url'])
    with open(path, "wb") as f:
        f.write(item['body'])
    # remove body and add path as reference
    del item['body']
    item['path'] = path
    # let item be processed by other pipelines. ie. db store
    return item

[1] another approach could be only store pdfs' urls and use another process to fetch the documents without buffering into memory. (e.g. wget)